Here’s a bold statement: the New York Yankees’ pitching rotation is about to get a major boost, but it’s not happening as quickly as some fans might hope. And this is the part most people miss—Gerrit Cole, the team’s ace, is making strides in his recovery from Tommy John surgery, but his return timeline remains firmly set at 14 to 18 months post-procedure. While there’s a chance he could pitch in Grapefruit League games before spring training wraps up, Yankees officials are cautiously optimistic about a June return, despite the possibility of an October comeback lingering in the air.
Cole himself confirmed this timeline on Friday, emphasizing that the 14 to 18-month window is backed by research and comparable cases. But here’s where it gets controversial—while Cole is a six-time All-Star and Cy Young winner with a stellar 3.18 career ERA, pitchers returning from Tommy John surgery don’t always bounce back to their previous form immediately. Some take upwards of a year to rediscover their dominance. So, while Cole’s return is undoubtedly exciting, it’s fair to ask: Will he be the same pitcher we remember?
During his first bullpen session since spring training began, Cole showcased a slightly modified windup, bringing his hands over his head instead of keeping them by his chest—a change he incorporated last summer. He described the session as ‘well executed and pretty good,’ highlighting his focus on rhythm and execution. Yet, he’s taking a day-by-day approach, avoiding setting specific performance goals. And this is the part most people miss—his humility and focus on the process could be key to his successful return.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone has been clear: the team won’t rush Cole’s comeback. ‘The last thing we want to do is push him early,’ Boone said, stressing the need for a smart, gradual build-up. After all, Cole hasn’t pitched in a game since the 2024 World Series, and his 2025 season was entirely wiped out due to injury. The Yankees’ rotation, currently projected to include Max Fried, Cam Schlittler, Will Warren, Ryan Weathers, and Luis Gil, will welcome reinforcements starting with Carlos Rodón, followed by Cole.
Speaking of Schlittler, he’s dealing with minor back soreness this week, though both he and Boone have downplayed its severity. Still, the Yankees’ pitching depth will be tested early in the season, especially without Cole, Rodón, and Clarke Schmidt, who’s also recovering from Tommy John surgery.
Cole’s refurbished right elbow feels ‘really good,’ he said, noting it’s different than it’s been in a long time. But the real question remains: How will his performance stack up once he’s back on the mound? Will he regain his elite status, or will there be a period of adjustment? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—do you think Cole will return to form quickly, or will it take time? The debate is open!
